The decision desk
AI card scanners: CollX vs Ludex vs My Cards AI
Compare card identification connected to a marketplace, category-based portfolios or desktop batch scanning and collection accounts.
Our take
Choose CollX for its collector marketplace, Ludex for scanning with sales reports and category plans, or My Cards AI for batches, set building and cost records.
The quick difference
3 tools, at a glance
Start with the fit. Read the individual breakdowns below before choosing. Scroll the table on smaller screens.
| Tool | Best fit | Main strengths | What to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| CollX | Collectors who want identification connected to trading and selling on CollX | Computer-vision card matching · Manual variant selection and catalog search · Collection tracking and marketplace · Pro Scan+ enhanced matching credits | Parallel and reprint matches need confirmation |
| Ludex | Collectors who want card recognition, sales references and category-based allowances | AI sports and TCG card identification · Parallel correction and custom prices · Recent sales and price reports · Collections, TCG decks and eBay listing workflow | Free scan count and saved-card cap are separate |
| My Cards AI | Collectors processing boxes of cards who also want set progress and cost records | AI phone and desktop image identification · Batch front/back pairing and editable records · Set building and cost/sales reporting · CSV export and eBay listing | Condition estimates are not professional grades |
Compare pricing, features, and source dates
Prices describe the named plan, not total cost. Different billing units are not directly equivalent. Scroll the table horizontally on smaller screens.
| At a glance | CollXVendor documentation | LudexVendor documentation | My Cards AIVendor documentation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Consider it for | Collectors who want identification connected to trading and selling on CollX | Collectors who want card recognition, sales references and category-based allowances | Collectors processing boxes of cards who also want set progress and cost records |
| Named plan / entry point | Pro monthly USD/month; annual USD99.99 | Lite monthly, one category USD/month; annual USD44.99 | Collector monthly after introduction USD/month; annual USD59.99 |
| Free option | Available | Available | Available |
| Documented features |
|
|
|
| Limitations |
|
|
|
| Integrations | CollX marketplace | eBay eligible listing workflow | eBay, CSV, Supported flatbed and sheet-fed scanners |
| Billing details | Pro USD9.99/month or USD99.99/year. Pro includes 500 Scan+ credits/month and unlimited collections; page describes regular users as limited to fewer than 500 cards. Scan+ is enhanced AI matching, not the same unit as a saved card or basic scan. Pro marketplace buying credit is a perk, not a cash discount against the subscription. Marketplace selling costs are separate. | Current web membership: Free 200 identified scans/month, portfolio up to 60 cards. Lite USD4.99/month or USD44.99/year, unlimited scans/portfolio for one sport or TCG and 200 scans across other categories. Standard USD9.99/month or USD89.99/year; Pro USD24.99/month or USD239.99/year. Standard advertises 50 and Pro 250 published eBay listings/month; Pro eBay publishing is US-only. Annual totals are upfront yearly commitments, not the displayed monthly equivalents. Confirm store-specific offers. | Collector USD5.99/month or USD59.99/year, first month USD2.99 for new subscribers then USD5.99; 500 AI scans, 10 grade estimates and 1500 Price Fetches/month. Dealer USD14.99/month or USD159.99/year; Shop USD49.99/month or USD499.99/year. First 30 days Free includes 100 scans and 50 Price Fetches; ongoing Free is 25 scans and 10 Price Fetches/month. Manual entry, collection size, reports and CSV are unmetered. USD12.99 buys 1000 nonexpiring AI scans only, not Price Fetches. |
| Last checked | Nov 3, 2026 Official source | Nov 3, 2026 Official source | Nov 3, 2026 Official source |
Choose a scanner by what follows the match
A useful trading-card scan must lead to the correct issue, printing and variant before its price reference means much. CollX, Ludex and My Cards AI use automated identification to reduce manual catalog work, then take the collection in different directions. CollX connects it to a marketplace. Ludex emphasizes scanning, price reports and category-based portfolios. My Cards AI adds desktop batches, set building and purchase-and-sale records. The right choice depends on whether the next task is trading a card, researching it or organizing boxes.
CollX
CollX uses computer vision to match a card photo against catalog images and then connects that match to a collection and its own buying and selling marketplace. When several variants or reprints look similar, the app presents alternatives and lets the collector choose the correct one. Manual catalog search is another route when the scan does not find a usable match. This makes the identity a record the collector can verify rather than an uneditable answer.
Pro adds enhanced Scan+ recognition using both card text and images, with a monthly credit allowance distinct from ordinary scanning. Unlimited collections, stacks, saved locations and additional listing photos support a growing library and sales activity. The marketplace is the main reason to choose the broader package: cards can move from identification into a listing within the same environment. A monthly marketplace buying credit is a membership perk, not a cash reduction of the subscription charge. Card references remain sensitive to the chosen variant, grade and available transactions, so a catalog match and an achievable sale price are separate conclusions.
Ludex
Ludex pairs AI card recognition with an explicit review step. After scanning, the collector can inspect card details, review the suggested price and recent sales, change a parallel and set a custom value. The verified card can then go into a collection or an eligible eBay listing workflow. That combination suits a collector who wants a price history alongside identification rather than only a single headline estimate.
Its membership structure is unusually category-sensitive. Free access has both a monthly identified-scan allowance and a smaller saved portfolio cap. Lite expands scanning and storage without limit for one sport or trading-card-game category while retaining a separate allowance across other categories. Higher tiers broaden access and add listing allowances. A collector focused on one category can therefore make a different choice from someone mixing several sports and games. Price reports and recent sales provide context, but the correct parallel and raw-versus-graded comparison still need attention. eBay publishing availability and monthly quotas should be checked against the chosen plan and supported region.
My Cards AI
My Cards AI is built around processing a collection as inventory. It accepts phone photos and desktop scanner images, pairs fronts and backs, fills editable card fields and organizes the result into sets. Windows, Mac and iPhone versions share an account, while Android uses the web app rather than a native Android download. A collector moving through several boxes has a different reason to consider it from someone scanning a single card at a show.
Purchase cost, expenses and completed sales are part of the collection record, alongside CSV export and eBay listing. Set building can use cards already in the library, while condition estimates offer an initial review rather than a professional grade. Market evidence also deserves a careful distinction: the vendor says its own recorded sales are preferred when available, otherwise current eBay asking prices are used and labeled. Those asking prices are not equivalent to completed-sale comparables. AI scans, grade estimates and Price Fetches have separate allowances, while manual entry and keeping the existing collection are not metered by card count.
A social marketplace or a collection workspace
CollX is the clearest fit when the collection should connect directly to other collectors on its marketplace. Ludex emphasizes the card detail, sales report and category portfolio, with eBay listing for eligible plans. My Cards AI organizes the physical library, set progress and cost records more explicitly. Someone selling occasional duplicates may value CollX listing flow; someone building complete sets from bulk scans may prefer My Cards AI. Ludex offers a middle route for collectors whose main repeated task is recognizing and researching cards across a chosen category.
What the price reference actually represents
CollX describes recent transaction-based references with fallbacks when direct sales are scarce. Ludex exposes recent sales, price history and parallel or condition filters. My Cards AI explicitly labels its own recorded sales or asking-price evidence. These methods should not be reduced to three interchangeable numbers. For an uncommon printing, the available evidence may be thin even when identification is correct. A raw card, a graded copy and a similar parallel are different comparables. The useful product is the one that exposes enough context to explain the figure in the collection record.
Scans, saved cards and other paid units
CollX Pro Scan+ credits buy enhanced matching and are separate from basic scanning. Ludex Free limits identified scans and saved portfolio size separately, and Lite unlimited access applies to one category. My Cards AI separates identification, grading estimates and market Price Fetches while leaving manual inventory unmetered. Their monthly prices therefore cover different amounts of work. Annual totals are annual charges, not monthly installment plans. My Cards AI introductory month and first-thirty-day free allowances should also be distinguished from normal renewal and continuing free access.
Which card scanner should you choose?
Choose CollX if its marketplace is part of how you collect and trade. Choose Ludex for identification linked to sales reports and a category-focused portfolio. Choose My Cards AI for batch intake, sets and purchase-and-sale records. Confirm the exact variant before using any price reference, and treat automated condition estimates as an organizing aid rather than a substitute for professional grading.
Sources & methodology
This article uses vendor documentation and our editorial analysis. We have not performed a controlled hands-on test. Product facts were checked on Nov 3, 2026; each profile records its own verification date.
- CollX profile and source notes · CollX: Scan sports cards to find out what they're worth · CollX Pro · CollX FAQ
- Ludex profile and source notes · Ludex | Sports Card and TCG Scanner with Price Guide App · Scan and Price | LUDEX · FAQ | LUDEX
- My Cards AI profile and source notes · My Cards AI: Sports Card Scanner & Collection Software · Help : My Cards AI · Card Scanner and Collection App Questions | My Cards AI