The decision desk
AI Reef Stocking Advisors: NextUpReef vs ReefMind vs ReefBot
Three saltwater aquarium apps for evaluating a prospective fish against your existing livestock and the conditions in your tank.
Our take
Use NextUpReef when you already keep detailed logs, ReefMind for a species-first check and follow-up questions, or ReefBot for a candidate review on iOS.
The quick difference
3 tools, at a glance
Start with the fit. Read the individual breakdowns below before choosing. Scroll the table on smaller screens.
| Tool | Best fit | Main strengths | What to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| NextUpReef | Reef keepers who already track water measurements and maintenance regularly. | AI stocking and compatibility review · Tank-aware chat and analysis · Parameter histories and selected controller integrations | Stocking Advisor requires Pro after the trial |
| ReefMind by Ian Fun | Reef keepers who want to look up a candidate and ask about it in the context of one tank. | Candidate compatibility checks · Fish and coral reference profiles · Tank-aware chat and livestock history | Recommendation depends on accurate species and tank entries |
| ReefBot | iPhone or iPad reef keepers who want a focused review of a fish they are considering. | Candidate species review · Aggression and tank-size considerations · Water test, livestock and dosing logs | iOS or iPadOS 18 and up |
Compare pricing, features, and source dates
Prices describe the named plan, not total cost. Different billing units are not directly equivalent. Scroll the table horizontally on smaller screens.
| At a glance | NextUpReefVendor documentation | ReefMind by Ian FunVendor documentation | ReefBotVendor documentation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Consider it for | Reef keepers who already track water measurements and maintenance regularly. | Reef keepers who want to look up a candidate and ask about it in the context of one tank. | iPhone or iPad reef keepers who want a focused review of a fish they are considering. |
| Named plan / entry point | Pro monthly (displayed $) displayed $/month billed monthly | Temporary free Pro access future billing unconfirmed | Pro monthly, US iOS USD/month billed monthly |
| Free option | Available | Unconfirmed | Unconfirmed |
| Documented features |
|
|
|
| Limitations |
|
|
|
| Integrations | Check the official product documentation | Check the official product documentation | Check the official product documentation |
| Billing details | The vendor lists Pro at $4.99 monthly or $39.99 annually. The 30-day trial requires no card, then reverts to free one-tank logging. Checkout currency follows the applicable app store. | The iOS description says Pro is temporarily free while the developer changes subscription access. Future limits, the promotion end date and the payable offer are unconfirmed. | The US store lists USD 4.99 and the developer documents monthly renewal after an eligible seven-day trial. Confirm the current stocking-advisor entitlement in the app. |
| Last checked | Nov 11, 2026 Official source | Nov 11, 2026 Official source | Nov 11, 2026 Official source |
Before you add a fish
Adding a fish to an established reef is a decision about the whole tank. The candidate’s adult size and temperament matter, along with the animals already occupying the same space. NextUpReef, ReefMind and ReefBot combine AI stocking guidance with records of what is in your tank, but each makes a different part of the decision easier to examine.
NextUpReef
NextUpReef adds the Stocking Advisor to an app for logging water results, equipment, dosing and livestock. After you enter the current inhabitants, the advisor can consider compatibility and bioload and suggest what you might add next. It is well suited to someone who already keeps a history and wants to make stocking part of that routine. A separate Reef AI Advisor looks across the tank’s recent state, and the chat handles follow-up questions.
The free tier maintains a single tank with basic logs and up to 90 days of chart views. The advisor is a Pro feature, available in a 30-day trial that does not require payment information. Afterward you can return to free logging or pay monthly or annually through the app store. Selected controllers can provide live readings, with the available actions depending on the hardware. The stocking feature starts with your livestock entries regardless of how you collect water readings.
ReefMind by Ian Fun
ReefMind by Ian Fun offers a candidate check against the current livestock and tank size. Its fish and coral reference profiles provide a way to start from a particular species, while tank-aware chat lets you ask about that candidate without re-entering your setup. If you are comparing fish for a compact reef, you can look up the animals first and then narrow the questions to how one of them may fit with your current stock.
The app also provides a tank rating and keeps a record of livestock, gear and water measurements. The rating is an AI summary and the compatibility screen is more directly relevant to a prospective fish. The developer’s US Apple listing currently describes temporarily free Pro access during subscription changes. The duration and future terms are unconfirmed. The app discussed here is the one linked to reefmind.io and published by Ian Fun.
ReefBot
ReefBot is Expi AB’s reef log for iPhone and iPad. Its stocking advisor lets you pick species you are considering and ask about aggression, compatibility and tank-size fit. A reader who already knows the two or three fish they are deciding among can use those dimensions to structure a shortlist. The broader app includes livestock and water logs, coral photo analysis and a dosing log, so stocking is one of several ways it works with your tank records.
The developer says tank data is stored on the device by default. Separate submitted AI features use remote processing. The vendor documents an eligible seven-day trial for Pro followed by a monthly subscription through Apple. Check the current stocking entitlement in the app, since the marketing plan list emphasizes the wider logging and photo features. ReefBot requires iOS or iPadOS 18 or later.
Choosing from the tank or from a species
NextUpReef starts from the logged tank and asks what addition might make sense given the current mix and bioload. ReefMind offers a natural path from looking up a fish to asking what it could mean for your tank. ReefBot concentrates on the candidate and gives you a way to ask specifically about aggression or the size of the setup. Those starting points matter if you are building a shortlist from scratch versus investigating a fish already at the shop.
How much context stays with the recommendation
NextUpReef is useful when the same app holds recent measurements and records of the current inhabitants. ReefMind keeps an editable tank and species context for further questions. ReefBot pairs its candidate workflow with local tank records and mobile logging. Entries such as the exact species and adult size are more informative than a loose common name, particularly when similarly named fish have different habits or space requirements.
Access before and after the first check
NextUpReef gives you a defined Pro trial followed by a free logging tier with the stocking feature locked. ReefMind describes a temporary Pro promotion, so its future terms are less predictable. ReefBot lists a monthly Pro plan after an eligible trial, with Apple managing renewals. These arrangements matter if you expect to ask occasional pre-purchase questions but log measurements throughout the year.
Which one fits
Pick NextUpReef for stocking within ongoing reef logs, ReefMind for species lookup and follow-up, or ReefBot for focused candidate questions on iOS. Check the suggested fit against reliable species care information before bringing an animal home.
Sources & methodology
This article uses vendor documentation and our editorial analysis. We have not performed a controlled hands-on test. Product facts were checked on Nov 11, 2026; each profile records its own verification date.
- NextUpReef profile and source notes · Official product and features · Feature entitlements, billing and trial terms
- ReefMind by Ian Fun profile and source notes · Official product and features · Developer US App Store features and Pro access notice · Product terms
- ReefBot profile and source notes · Official product and features · Expi AB Pro pricing, eligibility and renewal