The decision desk
AI Freight Invoice Auditing: Loop vs Intelligent Audit vs Raft
Checking a carrier bill requires shipment context, agreed rates and a way to resolve exceptions. Loop, Intelligent Audit and Raft apply AI to that work, but serve different operational settings and offer different routes from a discrepancy to a decision.
Our take
Choose Loop for policy-driven freight audit workflows, Intelligent Audit for audit and recovery with machine-learning insights, or Raft for forwarder shipment-cost matching.
The quick difference
3 tools, at a glance
Start with the fit. Read the individual breakdowns below before choosing. Scroll the table on smaller screens.
| Tool | Best fit | Main strengths | What to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loop | Shippers coordinating freight audit, carrier exceptions and spend controls | Contract and accessorial charge checks · Configurable document and approval policies · Carrier dispute handling through an Exception Agent | Automation depends on configured policies and shipment documentation |
| Intelligent Audit | Shipping teams seeking audit and recovery with analyst-supported spend intelligence | Freight and parcel invoice audit and recovery · DeepDetectAI anomaly explanations · Standardized carrier data and spend reporting | An anomaly is a signal for investigation, not proof of an invalid charge |
| Raft | Freight forwarders and customs brokers matching carrier bills to shipment costs | Multi-shipment invoice association · Line-item matching to buy rates and accruals · Contextual exception approval and system synchronization | Designed around forwarder and broker operations |
Compare pricing, features, and source dates
Prices describe the named plan, not total cost. Different billing units are not directly equivalent. Scroll the table horizontally on smaller screens.
| At a glance | LoopVendor documentation | Intelligent AuditVendor documentation | RaftVendor documentation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Consider it for | Shippers coordinating freight audit, carrier exceptions and spend controls | Shipping teams seeking audit and recovery with analyst-supported spend intelligence | Freight forwarders and customs brokers matching carrier bills to shipment costs |
| Named plan / entry point | Custom quote; price unconfirmed Check official source | Monthly subscription; custom quote Check official source | Custom quote; price unconfirmed Check official source |
| Free option | No ongoing free plan | No ongoing free plan | No ongoing free plan |
| Documented features |
|
|
|
| Limitations |
|
|
|
| Integrations | Check the official product documentation | Check the official product documentation | Check the official product documentation |
| Billing details | The current product and contact pages offer a sales discussion rather than a public rate. Subscription amount, billing commitment, invoice allowance, implementation and payment charges are unconfirmed. | The official FAQ describes a monthly subscription priced using annual shipment volume, modes and carrier count. The amount and contractual commitment are unconfirmed. The 90-day Catalyst trial targets smaller parcel shippers and is not a permanent free plan or a trial of every enterprise service. | The accounts-payable and contact pages invite a demo without publishing a numeric plan price. Billing interval, invoice capacity, integration costs and agent entitlements are unconfirmed. |
| Last checked | Nov 19, 2026 Official source | Nov 19, 2026 Official source | Nov 19, 2026 Official source |
Which freight billing problem are you solving?
A carrier invoice can contain the expected amount of data and still charge the wrong rate. This comparison focuses on validating transportation bills against shipment and commercial context. It separates the shipper's spend-control decision from the forwarder's need to match a creditor invoice to a job.
Loop
Loop brings invoice intake, contract checking and exception resolution into a shared transportation-spend workflow. Carriers can supply invoices through EDI, API, email or file upload; Loop extracts charges and compares them with contracted rates and accessorial terms. Its Policies capability makes requirements such as supporting documents, approval thresholds and variance rules part of the workflow. Clean invoices can progress while exceptions follow a different route. The current product description also includes an Exception Agent that opens carrier disputes and tracks them to resolution or escalation. This suits shippers who want the audit result to trigger an operational action rather than end as a discrepancy report. Coding, payments and spend views extend the scope, although the contracted service and transport-mode coverage should be established with Loop. Its central appeal is connecting charge validation with the next action on the invoice.
Intelligent Audit
Intelligent Audit combines freight and parcel auditing with recovery, payment services, reporting and transportation expertise. It standardizes carrier data so a team can examine spending at shipment, package or individual-charge level and compare carriers on a consistent basis. DeepDetectAI adds a different kind of signal: machine learning examines shipping history for unusual costs, service use or other patterns, with contextual explanations and analyst support. This makes the platform relevant when the question extends beyond whether one rate matches a contract to whether the wider shipping pattern deserves attention. Audit checks and anomaly detection complement each other; an unusual charge is not automatically an overcharge. Its managed expertise is particularly relevant to a shipper that wants help interpreting exceptions and pursuing recovery. The smaller-volume Catalyst offering is a separate entry route, so its trial should not be treated as access to every enterprise capability.
Raft
Raft places carrier invoice matching inside freight-forwarder and customs-broker operations. It identifies the shipment associated with an invoice, including invoices covering several shipments, and extracts line items for comparison with buy rates and accruals. Its agents can break charges across cost items and surface a mismatch with the relevant context. Finance staff handle the queue, while operational colleagues can review exceptions without working through the full accounts-payable process. Approved information can synchronize with a connected TMS, ERP or accounting system. The surrounding platform supplies orchestration rules, standard operating procedures and tracked work items. This suits a forwarder whose main difficulty is connecting the creditor bill to the shipment record and its expected costs. It is a more specific operational fit than a general shipper spend dashboard, and its usefulness depends on the connected systems and shipment data available.
Contract checks and unusual spending
Loop emphasizes invoice checks against contract terms and explicit approval policies. Intelligent Audit combines audit and recovery with DeepDetectAI's learned patterns, giving the team a second way to spot a problem that a straightforward rate comparison might miss. Raft emphasizes buy rates and accruals attached to a forwarder's shipment. These are different reference points, so the right shortlist begins with the records your team uses to establish what it should pay.
What happens after a mismatch?
Loop describes an agent-led carrier dispute flow with escalation when a decision is needed. Intelligent Audit pairs automated checks and explanations with recovery services and transportation specialists. Raft routes exceptions between finance and operational colleagues before updating connected systems. For a shipper seeking outsourced recovery support, Intelligent Audit warrants attention; for a forwarder seeking internal job-level approval, Raft addresses a more direct workflow.
Scope and commercial comparison
Loop and Raft invite sales discussions without public numeric rates. Intelligent Audit describes a monthly subscription shaped by annual shipment volume, modes and carrier count. A useful comparison therefore includes the quoted audit coverage, exception-handling responsibility and connected systems. Intelligent Audit's limited Catalyst trial is a way to evaluate that offering, rather than a permanent free service comparable with either other platform.
Which should you choose?
Shortlist Loop for connected shipper audit and exception automation, Intelligent Audit for audit and recovery with anomaly insights, or Raft for forwarder invoice matching against shipment costs. Official sources were checked on November 19, 2026. This is a documentation-based comparison, without claimed hands-on savings or accuracy results.
Sources & methodology
This article uses vendor documentation and our editorial analysis. We have not performed a controlled hands-on test. Product facts were checked on Nov 19, 2026; each profile records its own verification date.
- Loop profile and source notes · Official product · Official pricing or access · Official workflow documentation
- Intelligent Audit profile and source notes · Official product · Official pricing or access · Official workflow documentation
- Raft profile and source notes · Official product · Official pricing or access · Official workflow documentation